Hilltop Views

Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

Guillermo+Del+Toro+took+home+numerous+Oscars+for+%22The+Shape+of+Water.%22
Back to Article
Back to Article

Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

Guillermo Del Toro took home numerous Oscars for

Guillermo Del Toro took home numerous Oscars for "The Shape of Water."

Guillermo Del Toro took home numerous Oscars for "The Shape of Water."

Guillermo Del Toro took home numerous Oscars for "The Shape of Water."

Sierra Rozen

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






The Oscars took place on March 4 and, like always, it had its fair share of controversy. The night had its great moments, such as Frances McDormand encouraging the audience to push for inclusion riders and having all the women nominees stand up when she was collecting her award. The evening seemed to be getting even better when Jordan Peele and Guillermo Del Toro, both men of color, won awards in their respective categories. Alas, these achievements were soured by a proclamation of white feminism.

Nervous excitement was running through the crowd as Emma Stone stepped up to announce the nominees for Best Director. Unfortunately, Stone just had to make the comment “These four men and Greta Gerwig created their own masterpieces this year.” Now at first glance, this might seem like a passionate commentary on how the Oscar’s tend to be male oriented.

This is true, but we are overlooking the fact that two men of color were nominated in this category. Men of color have almost always been looked down upon and ignored when it comes to award shows. Oscar voters tend to only focus on white males when making their nominations. What we have here is a clear example of white feminism, something that can be defined as feminism that ignores intersectionality.

Intersectionality is classified as a theory that considers various aspects of humanity and sees them as interwoven with each other, instead of viewing them separately. Focusing on the fact that one woman was nominated, ignoring the milestone of having two men of color nominated and grouping them with the other white directors makes this a pretty ignorant comment to make.

In the history of the Oscars, there has only been a handful of people of color and women who have been nominated for the Best Director category. We should have been celebrating the fact that we actually had some diversity in this category this year. It also helped to make up for the fact that Peele’s movie “Get Out” was nominated as a comedy at the Golden Globes, even though it is obviously a horror movie that happens to have social commentary in it as well.

The running theme of degrading the Best Director category simply because it only has one female in it this year is a problematic thing that Hollywood has yet to recognize. Though in the past Hollywood and intersectionality have not exactly gone hand in hand, part of solving the problem would simply be acknowledging the problem.

If a celebrity identifies themselves as a feminist, they need to recognize that being a feminist includes supporting people of color and other marginalized groups. Being a feminist does not mean making snide comments about how there is only one woman director nominated. Being a feminist means appreciating the steps we’ve taken by nominating people of color and women, but also sending out a cry for more diversity, more inclusion and more intersectionality.

About the Writer
Sierra Rozen, Viewpoints Editor

I am Sierra Rozen – Communication major, Journalism and Women's Studies double minor and Viewpoints Editor for Hilltop Views. This is my sophomore year...

Leave a Comment

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Left
  • Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

    Viewpoints

    OurView: Death should not purify, excuse terrible actions of powerful men

  • Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

    Viewpoints

    Five reasons St. Edward’s should consider adopting a dead week

  • Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

    Viewpoints

    Mistreatment of asylum seekers is part of a long history of anti-Honduran sentiments

  • Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

    Viewpoints

    Texans must prioritize voting issues like they did the senate race

  • Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

    Viewpoints

    DACA recipients have the merits of any other, let them compete for scholarships

  • Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

    Viewpoints

    Abuse is no accident: abusers need more than time to be accepted

  • Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

    Viewpoints

    Faceoff: Santa Claus narrative promotes ostracism of low income children

  • Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

    Viewpoints

    Faceoff: Santa Claus provides sense of joy, magic for children

  • Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

    Viewpoints

    OurView: Students have opportunity to stop proposed Title IX changes

  • Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color

    Viewpoints

    Misplaced blame of California wildfires only worsens situation

Navigate Right

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






The Student News Site of St. Edward's University
Emma Stone Oscar comments ignore intersectionality, sideline men of color